Saturday, August 10, 2024

Don't Tell Me Who I May or May Not Insult! Reform UK's Section 5


Until today I was not aware of the Reform Section 5 movement. Now, I'm its biggest fan. 

I particularly like Atkinson's point that the "insulting words" test does not even require that there be a victim, just some expression that someone in power - who exactly? - deems insulting. 

He arrives at the same solution the U.S. Supreme Court did in 1931: the 'counterspeech doctrine' that says the solution to speech you don't like is more speech not suppressing other speakers. 

That's how free societies behave. Anything less is simply an all-purpose excuse to lock up any party whom the police disfavor.
 

No comments: